Scottish Government says gender recognition laws must 'take account of everyone's rights'

 (Photo: Unsplash/Adam Wilson)

The Scottish Government has said that some transgender policies, while "well-intentioned", may have gone too far.

The admission was made by Cabinet Secretary for Social Security Shirley-Anne Somerville in the foreward to a consultation into the draft Gender Recognition Reform (Scotland) Bill, published on Tuesday. 

The public consultation is taking place until 17 March 2020.  It follows a previous four-month consultation in 2018 into changes to the 2004 Gender Recognition Act. 

The proposals on the table include introducing gender self-identification, which would make it possible for a transgender person to legally change their sex without the current requirement for medical and psychiatric evidence. 

In order to make the change, they would need to have been living in their chosen sex for at least three months and state their intention to live permanently in this sex. 

Other proposals recommend lowering the age at which people can apply for a gender recognition certificate from 18 to 16. 

In the foreward to the consultation, Ms Somerville said that some of the debate had been characterised by "transphobia and misogyny".  She called for a "vigorous" but "respectful" debate on gender recognition. 

But she also admitted that some efforts to accommodate trans people may have come at the expense of the rights of women and girls. 

"I recognise that some organisations have changed policies whihc are not required in law. And I know that they have done so in a well-intentioned attempt to be trans-inclusive," Ms Somerville wrote.

"However they may have unintentionally made changes that make women feel uncomfortable and less safe. They need to take account of everyone's rights." 

When the Scottish Government first announced that it would be holding a fresh consultation into the changes, the news was welcomed by the Evangelical Alliance, which said that "greater clarity" was needed around the proposals. 

It was especially critical of plans to lower the age at which people can change their gender, calling the proposal "deeply concerning". 

"We will continue to engage with the Scottish Government on this issue, providing a clear and compassionate Christian response," it said at the time. 

News
Pope seeks prayers for peace in Christmas Day message
Pope seeks prayers for peace in Christmas Day message

The Pope asked people to pray in particular for the "tormented people of Ukraine" in his Christmas Day 'Urbi et Orbi' message. 

Who was St Stephen and why is he remembered on December 26?
Who was St Stephen and why is he remembered on December 26?

The carol says, “Good King Wenceslas last looked out on the Feast of Stephen.” In many countries, December 26, also known as Boxing Day, is better known as St Stephen’s Day. Stephen was the first Christian martyr. This is the story …

King Charles reflects on pilgrimage, reconciliation and hope in Christmas Day address
King Charles reflects on pilgrimage, reconciliation and hope in Christmas Day address

King Charles III used his Christmas Day speech to reflect on the significance of pilgrimage as he appealed to the nation "to cherish the values of compassion and reconciliation". 

2 Timothy 3:16 is Logos' Bible verse of the year, Matthew was the most studied book
2 Timothy 3:16 is Logos' Bible verse of the year, Matthew was the most studied book

One of the most-studied Bible verses of the year is from 2 Timothy in the New Testament, according to an analysis of millions of Bible study sessions that tracked how believers worldwide are engaging with Scripture.