Catholic hospital refuses hysterectomy for transgender due to religious beliefs

Evan Michael Minton was born a female but identifies himself as a man. Screenshot/Sacramento Bee video

A Catholic hospital in California has refused to perform hysterectomy on a transgender man, saying in a statement that such a procedure would violate its religious beliefs.

Patient Evan Michael Minton, who was born a woman but has identified herself as male, said Mercy San Juan Medical Center in Carmichael cancelled a previously scheduled surgery on Monday.

"When I got that news, I fell on the ground and cried uncontrollably," said Minton, according to The Sacramento Bee "It hurt because of the fact that I'm being discriminated against based on my innate and immutable characteristics, and it also hurt because it put everything in flux."

The 35-year-old state legislative aide came out as transgender six years ago.

Minton and his surgeon, Dr. Lindsey Dawson, were surprised by the decision taken by the hospital, which is part of the Dignity Health chain.

"I was a little bit blindsided by it," said Dawson, a Sacramento obstetrician gynaecologist.

The hospital said the procedure was against its anti-sterilisation policy.

Dignity Health refused to discuss Minton's case, citing privacy laws.

"In general, it is our practice not to provide sterilisation services at Dignity Health's Catholic facilities," said spokeswoman Melissa Jue, adding that hysterectomies are only allowed to cure a "serious pathology and (if) a simpler treatment is not available."

Dawson said Minton needed the procedure.

"Gender dysphoria is very clearly a pathology. It's a recognised state of health," noting that national obstetrics groups recommend that transitioning transgender patients be put on hormones and provided with appropriate surgeries," said Dawson.

Minton had already undergone double mastectomy and is scheduled to have phalloplasty, or male organ reconstruction surgery, on Nov. 23.

The cancellation has depressed Minton.

"It makes me feel like I want to crawl out of my skin. It brings me to my knees, it gives me anxiety, it makes me so emotional and that's when I know that I need to take the next step in my transition. ... I want to live as the complete man that I know myself to be. That's all," he said.

Ben Hudson, executive director of Sacramento's Gender Health Center, explained that "we know that these are life-saving procedures for transgender individuals. It's not up to (hospitals) to decide."

Despite the cancellation, Dignity Health officials helped Dawson set up with emergency privileges at Methodist Hospital of Sacramento, which is not bound by Catholic doctrines.

"I don't blame the staff. I don't blame the administrators. I blame the (Catholic) doctrines," Dawson said.

News
Sudan authorities use bureaucracy to stop church rebuilding and worship
Sudan authorities use bureaucracy to stop church rebuilding and worship

Authorities in Sudan are obstructing efforts by a church to rebuild and even to use their place of worship

Ramadan ‘offers a unique opportunity’ to share the Gospel, says missiologist
Ramadan ‘offers a unique opportunity’ to share the Gospel, says missiologist

Dr Emil Saleem Shehadeh has some sage advice for how Christians can engage with their Muslim neighbours and colleagues during Ramadan.

David Tudor hit with another lifetime ministry ban
David Tudor hit with another lifetime ministry ban

Having already been banned, the latest sanction merely reinforces an earlier decision.

Armenia’s Christian civilization is under existential threat - the UK must not stand idly by
Armenia’s Christian civilization is under existential threat - the UK must not stand idly by

The constellation of powers that produced the eradication of the Armenian Christian presence in Nagorno Karabakh now have their sights on the Republic of Armenia itself.