Amish Struggle with Forgiveness as Reality of School Killings Sets In

It is a daily struggle to live Jesus' message of forgiveness for the Amish community in Nickel Mines, Pennsylvania, which lost five girls at the start of the month in a schoolhouse shooting.

This week the President of US ministry Faith and Action, the Rev Rob Schenck, hand-delivered hundreds of prayers in binders for the victims of the massacre and their families, as well as for the family of the shooter, married father-of-three Charles Carl Roberts.

Rev Schenck was one of very few outsiders to be given the privilege of personally visiting the families of the children in the days immediately following the tragedy.

The families of the slain girls generously allowed Rev Schenck to participate in and witness firsthand some of their most intimate and private moments of grief, which included the preparations of the girls for their funerals by their grieving mothers and relatives.

Rev Schenck spent time with the family of Charles Carl Roberts shortly after Amish representatives assured them that the community forgave Roberts and laid no charge against the Roberts family.

Rev Schenck's experience with both the families of the victims and of the perpetrator was one that profoundly touched him and the extent of their forgiveness challenged immensely his own witness to the gospel's message to love our enemies.

He noted that at the time of his early pastoral visits, Amish church leaders explained that it would become progressively more difficult to sustain forgiveness as time passes. Mr. Schenck saw that in his most recent visits.

In a statement released after this week's visit to the Amish families, he said: "The Amish will tell you they are far from perfect. They struggle just as all of us do. Some of the family members told me this week they are having a very difficult time with their feelings as the reality of their loss settles in.

"The grandfather of one girl told me in tears he must depend on God each and every day for the strength to continue forgiving the man who killed his granddaughter and wounded the other children so terribly."

"Once again, these people are living out the gospel in front of us. Our experience with God's forgiveness is a daily one. Forgiving others is a process. No one is perfect. The Amish, like any of us, are struggling with their humanity. That's why God sent His Son, Jesus Christ, to us. And it's why we need His Spirit to help us.

"There are many dimensions to this terrible event. We are only now beginning to learn from it. The Amish say that's why God allowed it, to teach us something."
related articles
Legendary Worship Leader: Amish Girls' Death Not God's Will

Legendary Worship Leader: Amish Girls' Death Not God's Will

President of US National Clergy Council Reflects on Lessons from Amish

President of US National Clergy Council Reflects on Lessons from Amish

Amish Killings Schoolhouse Razed

Amish Killings Schoolhouse Razed

Killer's Wife Praises Amish Community for Mercy

Killer's Wife Praises Amish Community for Mercy

News
CoE sees surge in interest this Christmas amid reports of a 'quiet revival'
CoE sees surge in interest this Christmas amid reports of a 'quiet revival'

The Church of England has said that it is experiencing a surge in interest and that it has registered a record number of services this Christmas.

Nicaragua bans international visitors from bringing in Bibles
Nicaragua bans international visitors from bringing in Bibles

Nicaragua has gone up the league table of anti-Christian persecutors.

The little-known prayers written by Jane Austen
The little-known prayers written by Jane Austen

It is now 250 years since the birth of Jane Austen whose books and their many screen adaptations are beloved around the world. Not many people know that she was a devout Christian who also wrote devotional prayers. This is the story …

The Anglican worldview of Jane Austen’s life and novels
The Anglican worldview of Jane Austen’s life and novels

16 December 2025 marks the 250th anniversary of the birth of novelist Jane Austen, who was born in southern England in 1775. Her novels are steeped in biblical analogy and practical theology. This is the story…