Owners who refused cake for gay couple close shop

An Indiana bakery has officially closed its doors after being embroiled in controversy for months over its refusal to accept a cake order for a same-sex commitment ceremony. 

The 111 Cakery refused the order in March 2014, and co-owner Trish McGath had been taking a break from the business since the end of December. 

After McGath and her husband, Randy, declined to make the cake for two gay men, the story was picked up by a local news station. Soon, the couple became the talk of social media, and received threats as well as support for their decision. 

"We had people from all over — from Brownsburg and Lafayette," Randy said of the customers that rallied around them. 

The bakery was situated in a part of Indianapolis known for its strong ties to the gay community- a fact the McGath's were aware of when they opened their business there in 2012

Although they served gay customers, they "just didn't want to be party to a commitment ceremony" because such an event celebrated "a commitment to sin," Randy explained. 

The entrepreneur, who now sells recreational vehicles, said the decision was not an attack against the gay community. 

"There was zero hate here," said Randy. "We were just trying to be right with our God. I was able to speak to many homosexuals in the community and to speak our opinion and have a civil conversation. I'm still in touch with some.

Trish, who did most of the baking, complained that the business "was wearing her out," however. She also wanted to spend more time with her grandchildren. 

Aaron and Melissa Klein of Oregon's Sweet Cakes bakery were found guilty of discrimination in January after they refused an LGBT cake order two years ago. The couple faces paying up to $150,000 in damages, which will be determined on March 10.

Newsletter Stay up to date with Christian Today
News
What should Christians make of Tommy Robinson?
What should Christians make of Tommy Robinson?

In demanding that the likes of Robinson be banned from the Oxford Union, the clergy are in effect setting their own limit on freedom of speech and freedom of religion.

Christian woman persecuted by Iranian regime sentenced to 9 years in prison
Christian woman persecuted by Iranian regime sentenced to 9 years in prison

A Christian convert in Iran has been sentenced to nine years and eight months in prison on trumped-up charges linked to state security and anti-government activity.

John Lennox fears AI is making us lazy
John Lennox fears AI is making us lazy

Christian media leaders heard calls for courage, authenticity and discernment at the recent Revive 2026 conference.

Does the Church of England need to re-think its messaging?
Does the Church of England need to re-think its messaging?

If you look at the Church of England’s communications all that it ever seems to highlight is the good works that Christians do to improve the temporal well-being of their neighbours. It is right to highlight these things, but they are not the primary reason for the Church’s existence.