Disappointment as British Medical Association adopts neutral position on assisted suicide

The British Medical Association (BMA) has abandoned its historical opposition to assisted suicide after voting to adopt a neutral position on the issue.

The vote was close, with 149 in favour of moving to a neutral position, 145 against and 8 abstentions. 

Being neutral means the BMA will not support or oppose a change in the law.

The BMA now joins the Royal College of Physicians and the Royal College of Nursing in adopting a position of neutrality.

In a survey of BMA members last year, 40% said the medical body should actively support attempts to change the law, a third favoured opposition, and 21% said it should be neutral.

Following Tuesday's vote, the BMA said it will insist that doctors have legally protected rights to conscientious objection if assisted suicide is legalised in the UK. 

The change in position comes as Parliament considers Baroness Meacher's Assisted Dying Bill which proposes permitting legal suicide for the terminally ill subject to approval by two doctors and a High Court judge.

A previous attempt to legalise assisted suicide six years ago was defeated.

Dr John Chisholm, BMA medical ethics committee chair, said: "Assisted dying is a highly emotive and sensitive topic that inspires a broad spectrum of views and opinions both across the wider public and among the medical profession, for whom any change of law would have a profound impact.

"As evidenced by the results of our recent survey of the profession and in today's in-depth debate, doctors have a wide range of personal views on this important issue, and as such representatives have decided that the most appropriate position for the BMA, as the professional body which represents all doctors and medical students in the UK, to hold is to be neutral on the topic.

"This is an important day for the BMA and the medical profession, clearly demonstrating that we as an organisation are listening to our wider membership on such a crucial issue, and developing policy based on their valuable feedback.

"Moving to a position of neutrality means that the BMA will not lobby for or against a change in the law, but far from remaining silent on the issue, we will continue to represent the views, interests and concerns expressed by our members."

Commenting on the vote, Dr Gordon Macdonald, Chief Executive of the Care Not Killing alliance - which is opposed to assisted suicide - said the "only safe system is the one we currently have".   

He said that the experience of countries where it is already legal showed that promised safeguards could not be trusted. 

"The rapid extension of Canadian law to those with chronic disease, mental health problems and disability shows the fallacy of trusting in proposed legal safeguards and how only safe system is the one we currently have – a complete prohibition on state sanctioned killing," he said. 

"Our current laws protect vulnerable people and do not need changing, instead we need to refocus our attention on how to ensure we provide the very best palliative care to those who need it."

Danny Kruger MP, chairman of the All Party Parliamentary Group for Dying Well, said: "That even the most activist doctors group could not muster a majority for neutrality on assisted suicide shows just how unpopular it is. Clinicians recognise the dreadful, painful deaths an assisted suicide law would inflict, which is why many doctors and the Royal Colleges continue to oppose it."

Medics who support the status quo have warned against changing the law. 

Dr Gillian Wright, a palliative care specialist and researcher for the Our Duty of Care (ODOC) campaign group said: "The primary danger of assisted suicide is that people are devalued by society. This may be because they are ill, disabled or confused.

"Terminally ill and disabled individuals may begin to devalue themselves because they feel a burden. Legislation on assisted suicide, designed to give choice, may erode the choices of the most vulnerable."

Another ODOC member, David Randall, said: "Doctors have a duty to protect their patients from harm, and this means maintaining our opposition to assisted suicide and euthanasia. We must never allow vulnerable people to feel like their lives are a burden on others.

"International experience shows that there is no way to implement these practices safely, and our own personal experience as doctors teaches us that patients who are properly cared for seldom request assistance in ending their lives. We need better end of life care, not the legalisation of assisted suicide or euthanasia."

If you have been affected by any of the issues in this article, the Samaritans can be called for free 24/7 on 116 123.

50% OFF
18K Gold Plated Initial Pendant Necklace with Reinforced Box Chain
$6.49 $12.99
50% OFF
6-Inch Desktop Pottery Wheel Kit for Beginners with 2.2lb Air Dry Clay
$44.99 $89.98
50% OFF
Portable Folding LED Book Light Night Lamp with Floral Print Cover
$11.99 $23.99
26% OFF
Magnelex American Flag Windshield Sun Shade - High-Resolution UV Reflective Heat Shield (X-Large)
$19.9 $26.9
50% OFF
TailSphere 12-in-1 Turkey Tail Mushroom Immune Support Chews for Dogs (90 Count)
$13.49 $26.99
50% OFF
Aegend Diving Dry Snorkel for Adults and Youth with Top Dry Valve
$7.49 $14.99
50% OFF
Aegend Kids Swim Goggles for Toddlers 3-8 with Anti-Fog and No-Hair-Pull Strap
$4.49 $8.99
73% OFF
Smart Bluetooth Body Fat Scale with LED Display and Body Composition Analyzer
$21.58 $79.96
73% OFF
COSLUS C20 Portable Cordless Water Dental Flosser and Oral Irrigator
$7.99 $29.99
29% OFF
Pleco SK01 Solar Powered Robotic Pool Skimmer with App Control (Obsidian & Ivory)
$284.99 $399.99
52% OFF
Cordless Robotic Pool Cleaner C1 with Wall Climbing and App Control (Glossy Black)
$290.69 $599.99
52% OFF
NEWFAST Outdoor WiFi Extender with MU-MIMO and 3 Gigabit Ports (IP66)
$47.99 $99.99
51% OFF
NEWFAST AXE5400 Tri-Band USB WiFi 6E Adapter with 4 Antennas (NF-U357)
$44.45 $89.99
The $400 Mouse I Thought Was Ridiculously Expensive—Until It Changed How I Work
$0 $0
50% OFF
NEWFAST NF-RE523 AC1200 WiFi Extender - 1200Mbps Dual Band Signal Booster & Internet Repeater
$18.5 $36.99
36% OFF
Men's Athletic Running Shorts with Zipper Pockets - Lightweight & Quick Dry
$12.74 $19.99
Sealy 2-Pack Tritech 16" Twin Inflatable Air Mattress with Built-in AC Pump
$0 $113.99
20% OFF
INTEX Prism Frame 20ft x 52in Above Ground Pool Set - Round Steel Frame Swimming Pool
$695.99 $869.99
Gardner Pet 43" Heavy Duty Dog Crate with Wheels - Indestructible Folding Metal Cage (Black)
$0 $149.99
23% OFF
Ergonomic Office Chair - Big and Tall Desk Chair with Adjustable Lumbar Support
$279.99 $363.99
Newsletter Stay up to date with Christian Today
News
Murder investigation launched into Ann Widdecombe's death
Murder investigation launched into Ann Widdecombe's death

A murder investigation has been launched into the death of the former Conservative Cabinet minister after she was found dead at her Devon home with signs of serious injuries.

Disappointment as Jersey becomes first part of British Isles to legalise assisted suicide
Disappointment as Jersey becomes first part of British Isles to legalise assisted suicide

Opponents have warned it sets a ‘dangerous’ precedent. 

Ann Widdecombe, devout Christian and right-wing stalwart, dies aged 78
Ann Widdecombe, devout Christian and right-wing stalwart, dies aged 78

The longtime Conservative MP and later TV personality was known for her outspoken faith and defence of free speech.

Christian app for defeating porn addiction has over half a million downloads
Christian app for defeating porn addiction has over half a million downloads

The app features daily devotionals and accountability groups to help its users live free from porn.

Today's Top Deals

18K Gold Plated Initial Pendant Necklace with Reinforced Box Chain

$6.49
$12.99 50% OFF
View Deal

6-Inch Desktop Pottery Wheel Kit for Beginners with 2.2lb Air Dry Clay

$44.99
$89.98 50% OFF
View Deal

Portable Folding LED Book Light Night Lamp with Floral Print Cover

$11.99
$23.99 50% OFF
View Deal

Magnelex American Flag Windshield Sun Shade - High-Resolution UV Reflective Heat Shield (X-Large)

$19.9
$26.9 26% OFF
View Deal

TailSphere 12-in-1 Turkey Tail Mushroom Immune Support Chews for Dogs (90 Count)

$13.49
$26.99 50% OFF
View Deal

Aegend Diving Dry Snorkel for Adults and Youth with Top Dry Valve

$7.49
$14.99 50% OFF
View Deal

Aegend Kids Swim Goggles for Toddlers 3-8 with Anti-Fog and No-Hair-Pull Strap

$4.49
$8.99 50% OFF
View Deal

Smart Bluetooth Body Fat Scale with LED Display and Body Composition Analyzer

$21.58
$79.96 73% OFF
View Deal

COSLUS C20 Portable Cordless Water Dental Flosser and Oral Irrigator

$7.99
$29.99 73% OFF
View Deal

Pleco SK01 Solar Powered Robotic Pool Skimmer with App Control (Obsidian & Ivory)

$284.99
$399.99 29% OFF
View Deal

Cordless Robotic Pool Cleaner C1 with Wall Climbing and App Control (Glossy Black)

$290.69
$599.99 52% OFF
View Deal

NEWFAST Outdoor WiFi Extender with MU-MIMO and 3 Gigabit Ports (IP66)

$47.99
$99.99 52% OFF
View Deal

NEWFAST AXE5400 Tri-Band USB WiFi 6E Adapter with 4 Antennas (NF-U357)

$44.45
$89.99 51% OFF
View Deal

The $400 Mouse I Thought Was Ridiculously Expensive—Until It Changed How I Work

$0
$0 0% OFF
View Deal

NEWFAST NF-RE523 AC1200 WiFi Extender - 1200Mbps Dual Band Signal Booster & Internet Repeater

$18.5
$36.99 50% OFF
View Deal

Men's Athletic Running Shorts with Zipper Pockets - Lightweight & Quick Dry

$12.74
$19.99 36% OFF
View Deal

Sealy 2-Pack Tritech 16" Twin Inflatable Air Mattress with Built-in AC Pump

$0
$113.99 0% OFF
View Deal

INTEX Prism Frame 20ft x 52in Above Ground Pool Set - Round Steel Frame Swimming Pool

$695.99
$869.99 20% OFF
View Deal

Gardner Pet 43" Heavy Duty Dog Crate with Wheels - Indestructible Folding Metal Cage (Black)

$0
$149.99 0% OFF
View Deal

Ergonomic Office Chair - Big and Tall Desk Chair with Adjustable Lumbar Support

$279.99
$363.99 23% OFF
View Deal