Christian family to appeal after court dismisses school Pride parade complaint

Christian parents have said they will appeal after losing a legal challenge against their child's school for allegedly forcing his participation in a Pride parade.

Izzy and Shane Montague launched legal action against Heavers Farm Primary School after claiming that their son, who was four at the time, was not allowed to be withdrawn from the parade in 2018.

The parents also claimed that the school became "hostile" and "intimidating" towards them and other parents who questioned the promotion of LGBT ideology in the school. 

They allege that at a meeting with the head teacher, her daughter attended wearing a T-shirt with the slogan "Why be Racist, Sexist, Homophobic, Transphobic, when you can just be quiet".

Mrs Montague was also later banned from entering the premises or calling the school.

This week, the Central London County Court dismissed their religious discrimination claim.

In his ruling, Judge Christopher Lethem claimed that much of the school Pride parade's values were in alignment with the Montagues' Christian beliefs.

"The Claimants have focussed on the use of the word 'celebrate' seeking to instil it with the suggestion that it was advancing LGBT issues over other lifestyle forms. The delivery of the teaching does not bear this out," the judgment reads.

"The celebration was of diversity and acceptance of the differences between people; no hierarchy of equalities. Thus there was little in the Parade that was inconsistent with their beliefs.

"The Claimants have argued that the Parade and the teaching in general amount to weaponising education to undermine parental teaching to undermine parental teaching and foster the school's view. In the cold light of day I cannot ascertain the divergence between the teaching and the Christian views."

The judgment added, "In short there was no moral re-education and there was no case for exemption."

However, Judge Lethem did find that the school's communication about the event had been "poor" and that the T-shirt worn at the meeting between the Montagues and the head teacher had "set an entirely wrong tone". 

"[It] was entirely reasonable for the parents to view this as a hostile message," he said. 

On the banning of Mrs Montague from the school, the judge criticised the manner in which this was imposed, writing, "I cannot detect that Mrs Montague was given any opportunity to make representations in relation [to] the ban. There is no mention of it in the letter [informing her of the ban] and plainly there should have been.

"This could be indicative of a school that was riding roughshod over the parents' rights because of an animus against the Claimants because of their complaints."

Expressing disappointment at the ruling, Mrs Montague called the judgment "perverse" and said she was "deeply insulted" by the court's assertion that there was nothing inconsistent between her Christian beliefs and the Pride event. 

"Throughout this ordeal it has felt like I and my Christian beliefs that have been on trial," she said. 

"This is not over and we will appeal this perverse judgment which has made the evidence fit with the school's agenda.

"What are parents like us meant to do? The court appears to be as ideologically motivated as the school.

"No parent should have to go through what I, and so many other parents at Heavers Farm have, for wanting to protect the innocence of their children and raise them according to their own beliefs.

"I am a Christian, and I don't believe there is anything redeeming about forcing a 4-year-old child to march among rainbow flags and sing 'gay anthems'."

Andrea Williams, Chief Executive of the Christian Legal Centre, which is supporting the Montagues in their case, said the judgment was "remarkable for all of the wrong reasons".

"What this entire case stands for is that there are some schools in this country where biblical beliefs and Christians are not welcomed," she said.

24% OFF
MUCAR 892BT AI-Assisted Bidirectional OBD2 Scan Tool with ECU Coding (8" Touchscreen)
$478.79 $629.99
77% OFF
NOVETE Smart Countertop Reverse Osmosis Water Filter System with UV & Cooling (CRF0A-Qi)
$99.99 $429.99
36% OFF
G Gradual Men's Quick Dry Athletic Running Shorts with Zipper Pockets
$12.74 $19.99
17% OFF
X-Sense 10-Year Sealed Battery Combination Smoke and CO Detector (6-Pack, SC06-W)
$225.21 $269.99
50% OFF
18K Gold Plated Initial Pendant Necklace with Reinforced Box Chain
$6.49 $12.99
50% OFF
6-Inch Desktop Pottery Wheel Kit for Beginners with 2.2lb Air Dry Clay
$44.99 $89.98
50% OFF
Portable Folding LED Book Light Night Lamp with Floral Print Cover
$11.99 $23.99
26% OFF
Magnelex American Flag Windshield Sun Shade - High-Resolution UV Reflective Heat Shield (X-Large)
$19.9 $26.9
50% OFF
TailSphere 12-in-1 Turkey Tail Mushroom Immune Support Chews for Dogs (90 Count)
$13.49 $26.99
50% OFF
Aegend Kids Swim Goggles for Toddlers 3-8 with Anti-Fog and No-Hair-Pull Strap
$4.49 $8.99
73% OFF
Smart Bluetooth Body Fat Scale with LED Display and Body Composition Analyzer
$21.58 $79.96
73% OFF
COSLUS C20 Portable Cordless Water Dental Flosser and Oral Irrigator
$7.99 $29.99
29% OFF
Pleco SK01 Solar Powered Robotic Pool Skimmer with App Control (Obsidian & Ivory)
$284.99 $399.99
52% OFF
Cordless Robotic Pool Cleaner C1 with Wall Climbing and App Control (Glossy Black)
$290.69 $599.99
52% OFF
NEWFAST Outdoor WiFi Extender with MU-MIMO and 3 Gigabit Ports (IP66)
$47.99 $99.99
51% OFF
NEWFAST AXE5400 Tri-Band USB WiFi 6E Adapter with 4 Antennas (NF-U357)
$44.45 $89.99
The $400 Mouse I Thought Was Ridiculously Expensive—Until It Changed How I Work
$0 $0
50% OFF
NEWFAST NF-RE523 AC1200 WiFi Extender - 1200Mbps Dual Band Signal Booster & Internet Repeater
$18.5 $36.99
36% OFF
Men's Athletic Running Shorts with Zipper Pockets - Lightweight & Quick Dry
$12.74 $19.99
Sealy 2-Pack Tritech 16" Twin Inflatable Air Mattress with Built-in AC Pump
$0 $113.99
Newsletter Stay up to date with Christian Today
News
New guidance published to help churches use AI wisely
New guidance published to help churches use AI wisely

New guidance has been launched to help Christian leaders navigate the opportunities and risks of artificial intelligence.

Calls for diversity of opinion to be respected after Ann Widdecombe's death
Calls for diversity of opinion to be respected after Ann Widdecombe's death

Peers called for greater tolerance and respect for differing opinions during tributes to Ann Widdecombe in the House of Lords this week.

Church of England moving forward with slavery reparations fund despite legal challenge
Church of England moving forward with slavery reparations fund despite legal challenge

The Church of England is moving ahead with controversial plans to launch a £100m fund aimed at addressing historic links to slavery, although progress has been slowed by a legal challenge.

Independent review finds Church of England safeguarding response re-traumatised abuse survivor
Independent review finds Church of England safeguarding response re-traumatised abuse survivor

An independent review has concluded that the Church of England repeatedly failed a survivor of alleged sexual and spiritual abuse by clergy, finding that both its initial response to her disclosures in 2001 and a later national safeguarding investigation left her "further traumatised".

Today's Top Deals

MUCAR 892BT AI-Assisted Bidirectional OBD2 Scan Tool with ECU Coding (8" Touchscreen)

$478.79
$629.99 24% OFF
View Deal

NOVETE Smart Countertop Reverse Osmosis Water Filter System with UV & Cooling (CRF0A-Qi)

$99.99
$429.99 77% OFF
View Deal

G Gradual Men's Quick Dry Athletic Running Shorts with Zipper Pockets

$12.74
$19.99 36% OFF
View Deal

X-Sense 10-Year Sealed Battery Combination Smoke and CO Detector (6-Pack, SC06-W)

$225.21
$269.99 17% OFF
View Deal

18K Gold Plated Initial Pendant Necklace with Reinforced Box Chain

$6.49
$12.99 50% OFF
View Deal

6-Inch Desktop Pottery Wheel Kit for Beginners with 2.2lb Air Dry Clay

$44.99
$89.98 50% OFF
View Deal

Portable Folding LED Book Light Night Lamp with Floral Print Cover

$11.99
$23.99 50% OFF
View Deal

Magnelex American Flag Windshield Sun Shade - High-Resolution UV Reflective Heat Shield (X-Large)

$19.9
$26.9 26% OFF
View Deal

TailSphere 12-in-1 Turkey Tail Mushroom Immune Support Chews for Dogs (90 Count)

$13.49
$26.99 50% OFF
View Deal

Aegend Kids Swim Goggles for Toddlers 3-8 with Anti-Fog and No-Hair-Pull Strap

$4.49
$8.99 50% OFF
View Deal

Smart Bluetooth Body Fat Scale with LED Display and Body Composition Analyzer

$21.58
$79.96 73% OFF
View Deal

COSLUS C20 Portable Cordless Water Dental Flosser and Oral Irrigator

$7.99
$29.99 73% OFF
View Deal

Pleco SK01 Solar Powered Robotic Pool Skimmer with App Control (Obsidian & Ivory)

$284.99
$399.99 29% OFF
View Deal

Cordless Robotic Pool Cleaner C1 with Wall Climbing and App Control (Glossy Black)

$290.69
$599.99 52% OFF
View Deal

NEWFAST Outdoor WiFi Extender with MU-MIMO and 3 Gigabit Ports (IP66)

$47.99
$99.99 52% OFF
View Deal

NEWFAST AXE5400 Tri-Band USB WiFi 6E Adapter with 4 Antennas (NF-U357)

$44.45
$89.99 51% OFF
View Deal

The $400 Mouse I Thought Was Ridiculously Expensive—Until It Changed How I Work

$0
$0 0% OFF
View Deal

NEWFAST NF-RE523 AC1200 WiFi Extender - 1200Mbps Dual Band Signal Booster & Internet Repeater

$18.5
$36.99 50% OFF
View Deal

Men's Athletic Running Shorts with Zipper Pockets - Lightweight & Quick Dry

$12.74
$19.99 36% OFF
View Deal

Sealy 2-Pack Tritech 16" Twin Inflatable Air Mattress with Built-in AC Pump

$0
$113.99 0% OFF
View Deal