Keir Starmer criticised over trans comments

Keir Starmer (Photo: Channel 4 News)

Sir Keir Starmer has come in for criticism after saying it is "not right" to insist that only women have a cervix.

The Labour leader made the controversial comments while speaking to Andrew Marr on Sunday morning. 

He was asked on The Andrew Marr Show on BBC 1 whether it was transphobic to say that only women have a cervix. 

Starmer replied: "It is something that shouldn't be said. It's not right."

He spoke to the BBC as the Labour Party holds its annual conference in Brighton.

Controversy surrounded the event even before it began when Rosie Duffield, Labour MP for Canterbury, announced that she was withdrawing over threats from trans activists.

Last year, she tweeted that "only women have a cervix".

In further comments to the BBC, Starmer said he had spoken to Duffield ahead of the conference and told her it was a "safe place for her to come". 


READ MORE: Labour leader Keir Starmer thanks Christians for 'leadership' during pandemic


But he said there needed to be "a mature, respectful debate about trans rights" and that transgender people were among the most "marginalised and abused" in society.

He said, "We do everybody a disservice when we reduce what is a really important issue to these exchanges on particular things that are said."

Health secretary Sajid Javid has waded into the row, saying on Twitter that the Labour leader's comments are a "total denial of scientific fact". 

His response was praised by Maya Forstater, a woman who lost her job over trans-critical tweets.

"Thank you for saying so. [It] is unbelievable that in 2021 it is considered controversial that only women have a cervix," she said. 

Angela Richardson, Tory MP for Guildford, replied "Bravo". 

Professor Patrick Sturgis, Professor of Quantitative Social Science at the London School of Economics, said, "This simply is not a sustainable position."

The question to Starmer came after Duffield called on him to clarify his views on transgender rights. 

"I think many Labour women wanted a clear commitment and still haven't heard that," she said, according to The Times.

"It was disappointing that the discussion was framed solely around trans rights rather than women's rights, which is what concerns me most about this issue.

"Women now need to hear clearly from Keir Starmer that the Labour Party will listen and respond to our concerns about upholding and protecting single-sex services as outlined in the 2010 Equality Act."


More on this topic: If politicians can't stand up for Rosie Duffield, surely the Church should


The Archbishop of Canterbury, Justin Welby, has called for people to "disagree well". 

"Absolutely everybody has the right to be safe from abuse, threat or harm. That includes Rosie Duffield AND the transgender community," he said on Twitter.

"It's about time we looked for our shared humanity in our dealings with others, rather than the division."

Earlier this year, Starmer attracted criticism after apologising for a visit to Jesus House church in London because it has a traditional view of marriage.

He also deleted a video from his Twitter account that showed him visiting a pop-up vaccination clinic at the church. 

The retraction was made after he came under pressure from LGBT Labour. 

Rev Yemi Adedeji, a Trustee of London School of Theology, said at the time that it was "absolutely disgraceful" that Starmer had been "placed under pressure to reject both the church and the African community for their heterosexual belief".

News
'A lot' would change if Green Party disestablishes Church of England, says vicar
'A lot' would change if Green Party disestablishes Church of England, says vicar

The best response to suggestions that the Church of England would be disestablished if the Greens come to power is to do a better job of sharing the Gospel, an Anglican priest has said. 

AI still too inaccurate when it comes to Scripture, says YouVersion founder
AI still too inaccurate when it comes to Scripture, says YouVersion founder

YouVersion founder and CEO Bobby Gruenewald says artificial intelligence holds enormous promise. But when it comes to answering questions about God and Scripture, he believes the technology is not yet ready.

Church of Ireland marks St Patrick’s Day with worship, music and pilgrimage
Church of Ireland marks St Patrick’s Day with worship, music and pilgrimage

Church of Ireland dioceses and cathedrals have prepared a wide programme of worship, music and community events to mark St Patrick’s Day on Tuesday.

The story of St Patrick’s Day
The story of St Patrick’s Day

On March 17 every year, people in Ireland and across the world celebrate St Patrick’s Day. But who was St Patrick, and why is he remembered centuries later? His story is one of hardship, faith and a remarkable mission that changed the course of Ireland’s history.