The real reason we shouldn't blame God for tragedies

One of the most moving and powerful miracle stories in John's Gospel is introduced almost casually: "As Jesus went along, he saw a man born blind" (John 9:1).

The man's healing was to perplex and infuriate the super-spiritual people, the Pharisees who thought Jesus wasn't good enough to heal, but lead to one of the greatest declarations in all spiritual experience: "One thing I know, I was blind, but now I see" (verse 25).

Behind the miracle, though, there's an assumption: that the man's affliction must be someone's fault.

Any kind of affliction is hard to bear. It's even harder when people say it's your own fault. Jesus' disciples assumed that someone must have done something wrong, either the man or his parents (verse 2). Somehow he must have deserved it.

That's a view that is very tenacious. It was expressed by US evangelist Pat Robertson, who said that the people of Haiti were paying the penalty for the sins of their ancestors when the earthquake struck in January 2010. It was said of people with Aids. At an everyday level it can lead to stigmatising people with disabilities, so that they're seen somehow as less than adequate.

It's easy to write off these beliefs as due to ignorance or prejudice. But ideas like this reflect a deep-seated human instinct for justice. The idea that tragedy is random is abhorrent to us. Whether we have faith or not, it doesn't fit with the way we believe the world ought to be.

There are different ways of dealing with this. Atheists like Richard Dawkins simply deny there is anything to explain. The world is as it is, and there's no point in complaining about it. Others look for someone to blame. But what Jesus tells his disciples challenges all those ways of thinking.

"It was not that this man sinned, or his parents, but that the works of God might be made manifest in him," he says (verse 3).

He shifts the emphasis away from explanation to action: given that this has happened, how is it to be made to manifest God's glory?

This is a radical change. Instead of looking to explain the man's situation, he is going to change it. He moves the debate from analysis to effect, and does something that glorifies God.

So this is a story that teaches us three things.

1. Explanations aren't enough

Christians are good at analysing what's wrong with the world. We can see poverty, injustice and godlessness and explain exactly what effect they're having on people's lives. Karl Marx saw exactly the same thing in his own day, and famously wrote: "Philosophers have only interpreted the world. The point is to change it." Christians are to be world-changers, not just world-interpreters.

2. We are responsible

In Jesus' day, they thought people deserved their suffering because God was punishing them. Jesus turned this on its head: suffering is an opportunity for service. Blaming other people for what's wrong with the world is a way of refusing to take responsibility for changing it.

3. Service is mission

It was the mighty work done in the blind man's life, the gift of sight, that glorified God. When we do good, through a single intervention or through long-term love, care and commitment, and help change someone's life for the better, we're giving them a powerful testimony of the grace of God. Nothing we do is wasted.

Follow Mark Woods on Twitter: @RevMarkWoods

49% OFF
MANSPOT Electric Pubic Hair Trimmer - Waterproof Body and Groin Shaver for Men and Women (Black)
$20.39 $40
25% OFF
Lick-Safe Dog Paw and Nose Balm Stick - All-Natural Moisturizer with Coconut Oil for Dry, Cracked Pads and Snout
$11.69 $15.59
77% OFF
Men's Quick Dry Moisture Wicking Polo Shirt - High Elasticity Slim Fit Athletic Top (Runs Small)
$6.99 $29.99
46% OFF
Men's Running Shorts with Zipper Pockets - Lightweight, Quick-Dry, Multi-Sport
$12.95 $23.99
50% OFF
NEWFAST NF-RE523 AC1200 WiFi Extender - 1200Mbps Dual Band Signal Booster & Internet Repeater
$18.5 $36.99
48% OFF
G Gradual Men's 7-inch Workout Running Shorts - Lightweight, Quick-Dry, Comfort
$12.91 $24.99
30% OFF
NOVETE Under Sink Water Filter - 3 Years, 30,000 Gallons, High-Efficiency Filtration
$41.99 $59.99
50% OFF
HDPE All-Weather Adirondack Chair with Built-In Cup Holder - Tool-Free Assembly (Grey)
$69.99 $139.99
60% OFF
HOMETUK Clear Plastic Storage Bins with Dividers - 3-Pack Stackable Acrylic Organizer Containers for Fridge and Pantry
$19.99 $49.99
58% OFF
G Gradual Men's Fishing Shirt - UPF 50+ Lightweight Short Sleeve Button Down with Zipper Pockets
$14.99 $35.99
55% OFF
Everyfun 60" Rectangular Platform Tree Swing - 700lbs Heavy Duty Adjustable Outdoor Swing (Colorful)
$49.99 $110.99
61% OFF
Ekouaer Women's Casual Loose Jumpsuit - One-Piece Printed Sleeveless Wide Leg Romper with Pockets
$14.99 $37.99
36% OFF
Men's Athletic Running Shorts with Zipper Pockets - Lightweight & Quick Dry
$12.74 $19.99
61% OFF
Modern Ceiling Fan with Light and Remote - Reversible Quiet DC Motor
$69.3 $179.99
50% OFF
MOOKA H13 True HEPA Air Purifier for Home Large Room - 1076 sq ft Odor Eliminator
$39.97 $79.95
40% OFF
X-Sense XS01-WX Smart Smoke Alarm - 2.4 GHz Wi-Fi Photoelectric Fire Detector with Mobile App Alerts
$65.99 $109.99
11% OFF
VitaUp Beet Root Gummies with CoQ10 & Grape Seed - Nitric Oxide Circulation Support (60 Count)
$24.91 $27.91
Sealy 2-Pack Tritech 16" Twin Inflatable Air Mattress with Built-in AC Pump
$0 $113.99
20% OFF
INTEX Prism Frame 20ft x 52in Above Ground Pool Set - Round Steel Frame Swimming Pool
$695.99 $869.99
Gardner Pet 43" Heavy Duty Dog Crate with Wheels - Indestructible Folding Metal Cage (Black)
$0 $149.99
Newsletter Stay up to date with Christian Today
News
Anti-Christian hate crimes across Europe surge in May as arson attacks reach 2026 high
Anti-Christian hate crimes across Europe surge in May as arson attacks reach 2026 high

Anti-Christian incidents across Europe rose sharply in May, with new figures showing the highest monthly number of arson-related attacks recorded so far this year.

Gloucester churches come together to bless River Avon amid pollution concerns
Gloucester churches come together to bless River Avon amid pollution concerns

It is part of a broader campaign against river pollution as concerns remain about the amount of untreated sewage in the Avon.

Life beyond burnout: how Christians can grow in the desert seasons
Life beyond burnout: how Christians can grow in the desert seasons

Christian Today speaks to author and Anglican priest Tish Harrison Warren about growth in desert seasons and why the Church shouldn’t treat all spiritual weariness as a problem to fix.

Iranian-born bishop stands in solidarity with Britain's Jews
Iranian-born bishop stands in solidarity with Britain's Jews

2025 had the second highest number of antisemitic incidents on record.

Today's Top Deals

MANSPOT Electric Pubic Hair Trimmer - Waterproof Body and Groin Shaver for Men and Women (Black)

$20.39
$40 49% OFF
View Deal

Lick-Safe Dog Paw and Nose Balm Stick - All-Natural Moisturizer with Coconut Oil for Dry, Cracked Pads and Snout

$11.69
$15.59 25% OFF
View Deal

Men's Quick Dry Moisture Wicking Polo Shirt - High Elasticity Slim Fit Athletic Top (Runs Small)

$6.99
$29.99 77% OFF
View Deal

Men's Running Shorts with Zipper Pockets - Lightweight, Quick-Dry, Multi-Sport

$12.95
$23.99 46% OFF
View Deal

NEWFAST NF-RE523 AC1200 WiFi Extender - 1200Mbps Dual Band Signal Booster & Internet Repeater

$18.5
$36.99 50% OFF
View Deal

G Gradual Men's 7-inch Workout Running Shorts - Lightweight, Quick-Dry, Comfort

$12.91
$24.99 48% OFF
View Deal

NOVETE Under Sink Water Filter - 3 Years, 30,000 Gallons, High-Efficiency Filtration

$41.99
$59.99 30% OFF
View Deal

HDPE All-Weather Adirondack Chair with Built-In Cup Holder - Tool-Free Assembly (Grey)

$69.99
$139.99 50% OFF
View Deal

HOMETUK Clear Plastic Storage Bins with Dividers - 3-Pack Stackable Acrylic Organizer Containers for Fridge and Pantry

$19.99
$49.99 60% OFF
View Deal

G Gradual Men's Fishing Shirt - UPF 50+ Lightweight Short Sleeve Button Down with Zipper Pockets

$14.99
$35.99 58% OFF
View Deal

Everyfun 60" Rectangular Platform Tree Swing - 700lbs Heavy Duty Adjustable Outdoor Swing (Colorful)

$49.99
$110.99 55% OFF
View Deal

Ekouaer Women's Casual Loose Jumpsuit - One-Piece Printed Sleeveless Wide Leg Romper with Pockets

$14.99
$37.99 61% OFF
View Deal

Men's Athletic Running Shorts with Zipper Pockets - Lightweight & Quick Dry

$12.74
$19.99 36% OFF
View Deal

Modern Ceiling Fan with Light and Remote - Reversible Quiet DC Motor

$69.3
$179.99 61% OFF
View Deal

MOOKA H13 True HEPA Air Purifier for Home Large Room - 1076 sq ft Odor Eliminator

$39.97
$79.95 50% OFF
View Deal

X-Sense XS01-WX Smart Smoke Alarm - 2.4 GHz Wi-Fi Photoelectric Fire Detector with Mobile App Alerts

$65.99
$109.99 40% OFF
View Deal

VitaUp Beet Root Gummies with CoQ10 & Grape Seed - Nitric Oxide Circulation Support (60 Count)

$24.91
$27.91 11% OFF
View Deal

Sealy 2-Pack Tritech 16" Twin Inflatable Air Mattress with Built-in AC Pump

$0
$113.99 0% OFF
View Deal

INTEX Prism Frame 20ft x 52in Above Ground Pool Set - Round Steel Frame Swimming Pool

$695.99
$869.99 20% OFF
View Deal

Gardner Pet 43" Heavy Duty Dog Crate with Wheels - Indestructible Folding Metal Cage (Black)

$0
$149.99 0% OFF
View Deal