Transgender women can be housed in female prisons, court rules

High Court judges have ruled that it is lawful for transgender women to be housed in female prisons.

A legal challenge was brought against the Ministry of Justice over its policy of allowing inmates to be housed in accordance with their gender identity rather than biological sex. 

The woman who brought the challenge, named only as FDJ, argued that female inmates would be exposed to an increased risk of sex attacks should they be put with a transwoman with a history of sexual violence. 

Lord Justice Holyroyde accepted that the policy may cause "fear and anxiety" among women inmates and recognised that many female prisoners are the victim of sexual assaults and domestic violence,  The Telegraph reports.

But he concluded that maintaining the status quo balances the rights of women and transgender people. 

He added that the placement of trans female prisoners could be considered on a "case by case" basis by a specialist panel.

This panel should also be responsible for screening out those with a history of predatory behaviour and ensuring they are placed into specialist wings or under supervision, or alternatively housed in male prisons.

Lord Justice Holyrode said that such a panel could in his view "be expected to be astute to detect any case of a male prisoner who, for sinister reasons, is merely pretending to wish to live in the female gender."

He added: "I can accept, at any rate for present purposes, that the unconditional introduction of a transgender woman into the general population of a women's prison carries a statistically greater risk of sexual assault upon non-transgender prisoners than would be the case if a non-transgender woman were introduced.

"But that statistical conclusion takes no account of the risk assessment which the policies require."

A MoJ spokesman told the newspaper: "We are pleased the court agrees that the way we manage transgender offenders strikes the right balance between protecting their legal rights and ensuring the safety of all prisoners."

News
Is this a turning point for parish ministry in the Church of England?
Is this a turning point for parish ministry in the Church of England?

Sarah Mullally’s Synod address offers a hopeful sign that the Church of England is listening to its parishes and taking seriously the pressures on clergy serving several congregations.

Where is this ‘space for faith’ that the King speaks of?
Where is this ‘space for faith’ that the King speaks of?

King Charles says the Church of England protects space for faith, but his words ring hollow at a time when the state he heads is harassing Christians for silent prayer and criticising Islam.

Wes Huff confesses to plagiarism, asks for prayer: 'It was sinful'
Wes Huff confesses to plagiarism, asks for prayer: 'It was sinful'

Canadian-born Christian apologist Wes Huff issued a statement Thursday confessing that he sinned by extensively plagiarizing other scholars and asked his followers to pray for his family.

‘Beyond astonishing’ that schools are encouraging children to play GTA 6, Christian group says
‘Beyond astonishing’ that schools are encouraging children to play GTA 6, Christian group says

Schools offered pupils gaming vouchers, raffle prizes and other incentives to keep them in class as the 18-rated game went on sale.