Scottish court says legal definition of 'woman' excludes transsexuals

 Pixabay

The legal definition of 'woman' cannot include trans women, a Scottish court has said.

The Court of Session ruled in favour of feminist group For Women Scotland in its legal challenge against an expanded definition in the Gender Representation on Public Boards Scotland Act 2018.

The legislation was part of the Scottish government's attempts to increase the presence of trans women on public boards. 

For Women Scotland argued that the definition undermines the rights of women as protected by the Equality Act. 

In her judgment, Lady Dorrian said that the term 'transgender women' was "not a protected characteristic".

She also argued that including transsexuals who self-identify as women in the legal definition "conflates and confuses two separate and distinct protected characteristics".

"Changing the definitions of protected characteristic, even for the purpose of achieving the gender recognition objective is not permitted and in this respect the 2018 Act is outwith legislative competence," she said. 

Her judgment overturns a previous ruling in favour of the Scottish government. 

It comes in the same week as another judge ruled that it is lawful for people to choose their sex in the upcoming Scottish census regardless of what is on their birth certificate. 

News
Suspended Christian nurse accuses nursing body of 'discrimination'
Suspended Christian nurse accuses nursing body of 'discrimination'

A Christian nurse suspended since April after refusing to use a transgender patient's preferred pronouns has accused the Royal College of Nursing (RCN) of "discrimination". 

Church in Wales 'road map' for same-sex blessings is 'distressing'
Church in Wales 'road map' for same-sex blessings is 'distressing'

Orthodox Anglicans have accused bishops in the Church in Wales of "misleading" statements as it moves towards making same-sex blessings permanent. 

Tony Wales: a man with an unrivalled knowledge of the worldwide publishing
Tony Wales: a man with an unrivalled knowledge of the worldwide publishing

Tony Wales, who passed away on 28 October, was co-founder of Lion Publishing with David and Pat Alexander. Julia Cameron pays tribute. 

Zelensky accused of 'crime against humanity' in treatment of Moscow-aligned Orthodox Church
Zelensky accused of 'crime against humanity' in treatment of Moscow-aligned Orthodox Church

Real life is very rarely about the "goodies" and the "baddies".