CTindex - Christian Today UK Interactive Catalogue
Society

Christians Join Human-Animal Embryo Debate

Christian experts join panel at public meeting on whether to allow research into human-animal embryos.

by Maria Mackay
Posted: Thursday, June 28, 2007, 12:34 (BST)
Font Scale:A A A

"Adult stem cells are a very valid research model," he said. "But to my mind we should investigate both models because we don't absolutely know that adult stem cells are going to be the panacea to cure all human diseases, just as we don't know that embryonic stem cells are going to be any better."

Opponents fear that the creation of hybrid embryos could be the first step on a slippery slope into unethical science, although Dr Armstrong assured the audience that human-animal embryos would never be implanted into an animal or a woman.

Mr Cornwell voiced scepticism over whether finding a cure for degenerative diseases justified the use of human-animal embryos.

"We are allowed surely to be sceptical about whether this is quite the right way to reach those benefits," he said. "You don't have to be a religionist to believe there is such a thing as human dignity and it seems pretty obvious to me that to mix human and animal life is arguably an attack on human dignity."

Josephine Quintavalle, Co-founder of Comment on Reproductive Ethics (CORE) and also on the panel, said that research on stem cells from human-animal embryos was a "huge waste of money" and "fraught with difficulty". She called instead for more investment into adult stem cell research and umbilical stem cells.

Dr Bellamy, who is also a member of the Church of England's Mission and Public Affairs Council, said that the Church of England was willing to support research on human-animal embryos conducted within a 14 day period. The fourteenth days marks the point when the embryo is no longer regarded as a set of cells but rather as an individual.

He also stressed that using human-animal embryos for research into medical cures would have to be carefully regulated, conducted within a very narrow framework and only resorted to in cases where there was a "serious medical need" to be addressed.
.
"The proviso is that if research doesn't work then licenses shouldn't be issued and the research should be directed at reprogramming adult cells so that embryos of this form need not be created," he said, adding that it was necessary to at least explore the possibilities of human-animal embryos in light of the "Christian mandate to heal".

Opinion at the meeting remained mixed. Fourty-eight per cent of participants polled at the meeting agreed they "would not be happy to receive therapies derived from human/animal embryos".

The HFEO will carry out a larger opinion poll next month on 2000 people to further gauge public opinion on human-animal embryos.



continue to read > 1 | 2
Copyright © 2009 Christian Today. All rights reserved.
This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.
The comments below are readers' personal opinions and are in no way intended to reflect the editorial opinion of Christian Today.

Added: Monday, July 2, 2007, 20:13 (BST)

"...to mix human and animal life is arguably an attack on human dignity."

Human and animal life are already mixed. To be human is to share 98 percent of our genes with chimpanzees.

Phil Tompkins, Issaquah, Washington, USA

Google Advertisement
Externally generated - Report offensive links here
World Headline
Church's job is to proclaim the Gospel, say US Christians

Church's job is to proclaim the Gospel, say US Christians

Evangelical, Orthodox and Catholic leaders who unveiled the "Manhattan Declaration" on Friday insisted the document is...
Sponsored Features
Bible Educational Services is committed to telling the next generation the praiseworthy deeds of the Lord. Psalm 78: 4. To download free bible lessons or learn about Postal Bible Schools visit Enrich your love life, marriage and relationships through education and counselling. Train to become a certified marriage and family educator and change lives for good.
Google Advertisement
Externally generated - Report offensive links here